9 Comments
User's avatar
Brian Moore's avatar

The most interesting thing to me would be the association with the sea - I always got the impression that god came from a history of sky gods? I like the water association better though.

Expand full comment
Petros Koutoupis's avatar

As folks became more dependent on the land and agriculture, rain was a necessity for both crops and basic drinking water. How these different deities and spirits over their own respective domains eventually melded into one is not clearly understood. Some scholars believe it became a necessity both for unity and for cultural survival. It was just easier to say “Our God” instead of “the god of so and so”.

Expand full comment
Petros Koutoupis's avatar

The sea played a huge role in that region. It connected the ancients with a much wider world.

Expand full comment
Brian Moore's avatar

Definitely, I was just wondering where the "sky" elements crept in over the years. The christian/jewish/greek god/zeus all seem closer (at least in imagery) to a fertile crescent sky god - I wonder when that changed.

Expand full comment
Genghis Galahad's avatar

@pkoutoupis gives new meaning to the song line: “I, the Lord of Sea and Sky…”

Expand full comment
Kristin Mathis's avatar

Great thought-provoking piece! I'll be returning to this again, I think.

Expand full comment
Ambrose Andreano 🐦‍⬛'s avatar

YHWH/El’s associations with water has a striking similarity with Enki/Ea, and then other characteristics sound more like Enlil/Ellil.

Expand full comment
Avery Burns's avatar

Ur had a celestial father, supernal mother and the son (represented as a golden calf). Abraham fled from Ur.

Interesting isn't it? That's all. Just Interesting.

I believe in the Lord of Hosts. The Almighty. I have good reason.

Expand full comment
Chris Batty's avatar

Brilliant! Clear presentation & insight.

Expand full comment